New free website review service -

Do you have a question? Post it now! No Registration Necessary.  Now with pictures!

Threaded View

Hello all,

I have just released a new tool for web developers. The site is called It allows you to get free reviews of your web pages,
written by other web developers. works by asking the user to submit the URL of their
page, then to review someone else's page using a structured review
form. In this way everyone gets the feedback they need.

The service can be found at

I hope you'll give it a look, I think you'll really like it.

Kind regards,
Jonathan Matthews

Re: New free website review service - wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it

Doesn't bode well when your home page fails to validate with 36 errors.

Besides, if I want reviews, I'll get them from the folk here. Also free,
and most of them are actually COMPETENT.

Re: New free website review service

Quoted text here. Click to load it

I will give you the benefit of the doubt that this isn't a simple spamming
attempt to get traffic to your site.

However, it may be worth getting some things sorted while you are still in
"beta" stages. (Following the headings you have on the page:-)

1.    Are there any errors or omissions?

Sort out your page code and check it on lots of different browsers. At the
bare minimum see how it looks on IE/FF/Opera on a Windows PC. If you get the
code sorted you can be reasonable sure it will render on other platforms.

Look at your CSS and try to add in some other font options. For example, not
everyone has Arial on their computers which means they will see something
different than you may have intended. If you don't care what font they see
the page in, why specify it at all?

As for content - it is very sparse, I suppose you are going for the
minimalist-Google approach. If so, then from what I have seen so far it is
not missing anything.

Slightly more information would be nice - despite your claim that email
addresses are not captured there is no real reason for any one to believe
you. They have no way of contacting you if there is a problem etc. This
could be looked into.

2.    Does it bring across the impression I intended?

No idea. What impression did you intend?

3.    Does my page appeal to others?

Not to me. It looks a bit like a Windows XP "cute" theme going on here.
However, others obviously like it.

4.    Is the content interesting?

What content?

Re: New free website review service

Fleeing from the madness of the  jungle
and said:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

However, my news service disagrees with you :)

William Tasso

whither a trophy?

Re: New free website review service

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Often the case I suspect :-) (and probably quite right too....)

Site Timeline